Modern Exchange and its Comparison with Old Exchange Environment
Read time 5 minutes
Whenever a new iteration of Exchange Server emerges, it ignites a palpable excitement among users and industry experts alike, who eagerly embrace it with fervent curiosity. Over the years, Exchange has undergone a steady and transformative evolution. This article aims to delve into the concept of a “modern” Exchange and elucidate its significance when juxtaposed with the legacy Exchange environment.
Many Exchange experts widely endorse transitioning from older versions such as Exchange 2013 to 2016, 2007, or the modern Office 365 environment, and this consensus is grounded in compelling reasons. The contemporary Exchange architecture boasts significant improvements and incorporates cutting-edge features like Autodiscover, Exchange CAS, Exchange Web Services, among others, which greatly enhance the overall user experience. To grasp the concept of ‘modern’ in this context, it’s essential to scrutinize the features present in both legacy and contemporary Exchange versions.
Exchange 2007 marked the inception of modern Exchange versions. While Exchange 2007 does exhibit certain distinctions compared to Exchange 2013, Exchange 2016, and Exchange Server 2019, collectively, they all fall within the realm of contemporary Exchange solutions.
| Classic Exchange | Modern Exchange |
|
|
Now, it would be nice to discuss these features in detail.
When an Exchange client needs to access its mailbox, it must establish a connection with the Exchange Mailbox Server. In earlier versions of Exchange, the client would connect directly to the Exchange Mailbox Server. However, this presented a challenge as users were required to manually input the server details responsible for hosting their mailboxes.
In contemporary iterations of Exchange, clients establish connections with the Mailbox Server through the intermediary known as the Exchange Client Access Server (CAS). Importantly, Exchange clients are not required to manually input the server name. Instead, the Exchange CAS Server adeptly receives the client’s request and autonomously identifies the server responsible for housing the mailbox. The pivotal role of discovering the Exchange CAS Server is seamlessly executed by the Autodiscover feature.
In the previous Exchange environment, the process of setting up an Outlook mail profile was a manual task. Users had to gather a range of technical information, including the Exchange Server’s name used as an RPC Proxy server, the authentication protocol, the internal Exchange Mailbox Server name, and more. This method could be somewhat inconvenient and posed a risk of errors due to the possibility of entering incorrect information. Fortunately, there is an alternative option for automating the creation of Outlook mail profiles, which involves relying on tools such as the Office Resource Kit and PRF files.
Creating an Outlook mail profile in today’s Exchange environment has become remarkably streamlined. Users can effortlessly initiate the process by simply double-clicking on the Outlook option within an Active Directory environment. From there, Outlook autonomously searches for and establishes a connection with the Exchange CAS server. It adeptly handles the authentication process bidirectionally, expertly configuring settings via Exchange CAS to seamlessly craft the Outlook mail profile.
The legacy Exchange environment lacks any defined Exchange Server roles, in stark contrast to Exchange 2003, which introduced the concept of server roles. Nevertheless, the roles in Exchange 2003 are markedly distinct and less sophisticated when compared to the modern Exchange Server roles in use today.
In Exchange 2007, the revolutionary concept of Exchange Server roles was introduced, where each role encompassed a distinct set of tasks and functionalities. Notably, Exchange 2007 and its successor, Exchange 2010, featured a total of five distinct Exchange Server roles: the Exchange CAS Server role, Exchange Mailbox Server role, Exchange Hub Transport Server role, Exchange Edge Transport Server role, and the Exchange Unified Messaging role.
However, with the evolution of Exchange in subsequent versions, such as Exchange 2013 and Exchange 2016, the architecture was streamlined, consolidating the roles. These later iterations of Exchange Server retained only two core server roles: the Exchange CAS Server role and the Exchange Mailbox Server role. This simplification continued in Exchange Server 2019.
The legacy Exchange infrastructure relies on the RPC protocol to facilitate Outlook’s access to information stored in the Exchange public folders. The Exchange Free/Busy time service, which depended on these public folders for data, introduced certain challenges. This process involved the initial storage of information within public folders, followed by the cumbersome step of replicating it across various Exchange public folder stores.
Modern Exchange has phased out the use of public folders in favor of a more efficient approach: the Exchange Web Services (EWS) method. This method utilizes the HTTP (or HTTPS) protocol to facilitate communication between the Exchange client and the Exchange Server, particularly the server with the Client Access Server (CAS) role. The CAS Server serves as the intermediary that connects the client to its designated Mailbox Server, facilitating the seamless retrieval of the necessary data.
There are subtle distinctions in the roles of Exchange servers across various versions, such as Exchange 2007, Exchange 2010, and Exchange 2013. In the former versions (2007 & 2010), the Exchange Server CAS is tasked with providing the infrastructure for Exchange Web Services. In contrast, the latter version (2013) assigns this responsibility to the Exchange Mailbox Server. The most recent iteration, Exchange 2019, offers enhanced security, performance, simplified management and administration, as well as potent hybrid capabilities, among other features. These advancements make email management more convenient and efficient for both administrators and users, thanks to its updated capabilities.
A significant generational shift occurred within the world of Exchange when Exchange 2007 was introduced. This pivotal release brought forth a wave of modern features, including Autodiscover, Exchange Server CAS, Exchange Server Roles, Exchange Web Services (EWS), and various other innovations, marking the dawn of the modern Exchange Server era. This transition not only elevated the functionality of Exchange Servers but also greatly improved user experience, making it noticeably more user-friendly for those working with the newer Exchange Server iterations.
